Manufactured Spending Techniques with Gift Cards

Hopefully by now, you’ve read a few of my previous articles and have gotten started in the process of travel hacking. If you haven’t, you can start here:

I’ve already discussed the low hanging fruit of manufactured spending, like Amex Serve. Serve allow you to “spend” $1,000 per month in your pajamas at home. A Very easy, very valuable way to meet minimum spend requirements for Amex credit card bonuses.

However, there are times when you will need to manufacture spend more than $1,000 per month. This would occur if the credit card has a high minimum spend requirement, or if you apply for multiple cards at once and are trying to meet multiple spend requirements. No worries, there are ways to “spend” more.

Most of these other techniques involve gift cards in some form. This is because it’s relatively easy to turn gift cards back into cash, which can be used to pay off the credit card balance. I won’t discuss every single option available, as there are many, but I will talk about a couple of the best methods that take the least amount of time.

American Express Gift Cards

Update: As of 8/26/15, portals are not paying cash back for cards over $200. That effectively renders Amex gift cards dead for manufactured spending. Skip this section and read below under Visa Gift Cards.

American Express (Amex) gift cards are the favorite manufactured spending method of many travel hackers. This is because you can actually make money during this manufactured spending process. Here is how that works:

  1. Liquidate Amex Gift CardApply for a credit card with a great signup bonus, and get approved.
  2. Use that credit card to buy American Express gift cards through an online shopping portal.
  3. Receive Amex gift cards and liquidate them as quickly as possible.

The shopping portals will pay you cash back or extra miles when you purchase the gift cards. This may seem insignificant at first, but it is not. It is a fantastic opportunity to earn lots of miles/points while getting paid.

How about a real life example? Let’s say you apply for the excellent offer on the Chase Ink card offering 50,000 Ultimate Rewards (UR) after spending $5,000 in 3 months.

No, let’s get crazy and say you went and applied for both the Chase Ink and the Chase British Airways (BA) Visa (Compare Both Here), which offers 50,000 miles after spending $2,000 in 3 months. That means you need to spend $7,000 in 3 months to get 100,000 bonus miles between both cards. No problem:

  1. Apply and get approved for each
  2. Buy $5,000 of Amex gift cards on the Bold and $2,000 on the Barclay card through an online portal
    • Earn 2% cash back or miles from the portal** (which is $140 on $7k purchase)
    • Earn 100,000 total miles from the signup bonuses (50k Chase UR + 50k BA miles)
    • Earn 3,000 more BA miles for the $3,000 spend (BA card is 1x mile per dollar on all purchases) and 5,000 UR for the $5,000 spend (Chase Ink card is 1x on generic online purchases)
  3. Liquidate $7,000 of Amex gift cards as quickly and cheaply as possible

As you can see from the example above, you earn the portal rewards in addition to the normal credit card rewards and any signup bonuses. All in all, you’d net 108,000 miles and $140 cash minus the $3.95 fee for each Amex gift card that you buy. Not bad…

A Few Caveats

  • In my example above, I used 2% cash back from a portal. This is not a guarantee and portal rates change constantly. You have to compare the current rates before you make a purchase, and the best place to do that is CashBackMonitor
  • There are purchase fees and shipping charges, but premium shipping is free for the first 90 days, per account.
  • The process is not always so neat, and it can get downright annoying. Sometimes Amex cancels orders for no reason at all, and you’ll be forced to try again. The failed charge is often pending on your credit for a week…
  • Most credit card issuers code Amex gift cards as a purchase, which is what we want. But a few (some Citi cards), will code it as a cash advance, which should always be avoided.
  • For more details and real life examples, read this entire Flyertalk thread.

How to Liquidate Amex Gift Cards

You probably don’t want $7,000 in gift cards laying around the house, so let’s talk about liquidation.

Unfortunately for us, Amex gift cards do not, will not, and cannot ever have a pin code (like a debit card). This is problematic because many of the easiest and most efficient liquidation methods require a pin to be run as debit. Despite that problem, we still have a number of options available to us:

Normal Spending – Amex gift cards can be used as credit at any place that accepts American Express.

Merchant Gift Cards** – You can use Amex cards as credit to purchase other gift cards that you might need. This presents another opportunity to use a cash back portal and earn a little something on the exchange. For example, ShopDiscover portal frequently offers 10% back at Kmart and Sears. Simply use your Amex gift card to pay. Note, this method only makes sense if you are planning a purchase at another store and were going to spend the money anyway.

** For these methods, you need to first register your Amex gift cards in your name. This is required when you run them as credit online. To do so, call Amex (1-800-297-7327), and talk to a representative, or do it online. Tell them that you would like to register your name and address to your Amex gift card.

Visa Gift Cards

Visa Gift Cards (VGCs) are both a method of liquidation and a manufactured spending opportunity, depending on how you go about the process. They are far more valuable than Amex gift cards because VGCs will have a pin, and can be used as debit (which allows many additional liquidation methods, see below).

Continuing from above, you can use Amex gift cards to purchase Visa gift cards. In that way, the Amex gift cards simply act as an intermediate step that provides additional cash back/points along the way (no longer working since portals aren’t paying cash back).

Some people prefer not to mess with portals, shipping, and the whole Amex process, so they choose to buy Visa Gift Cards directly with their credit card, cutting out the profits and hassles of Amex. This is fine too. Either way, you will end up with VGCs to liquidate.

Fees

VGCs are not free to purchase. However you buy them, you will pay an upfront fee. Most of the time, this falls right around the 1% mark. This is why people choose to first buy Amex gift cards. It helps offset the cost.

Please realize that 1% is not a lot in the grand scheme of things. For our $7,000 example above, you would pay roughly $70 in fees if you simply bought VGCs directly with your credit card. That’s nothing considering the cash value of the 108,000 miles earned could be more than $2,500 in travel, depending on how you value the points/miles.

How to Purchase VGC

The easiest method of purchase is through CVS pharmacy (if you have them in your area). They sell a variety called the OneVanilla Visa Gift Card, and it looks like this:

vanilla visa gift card

 

As you can see, the maximum amount you can load on each card is $500. Each card carries a $4.95 upfront fee. Which is $9.90 in fees per $1,000 of VGC, which is very close to the 1% I mentioned above.

To hit the $7,000 minimum spend requirement in our example, you need to purchase 14 VGC. Don’t try that at 1 store, in 1 day. The limit at CVS is $2,000 per 24 hour period, per person.

You can choose to use your credit card directly, or your Amex gift cards that were already purchased. To make things easier for yourself, opt for personalized Amex gift cards when you purchase them if you are going this route. They come with your name printed on the gift card, which pleases cashiers.

If you don’t have a CVS nearby, many grocery stores carry regular Visa Gift Cards that are pretty much identical. They still have a $500 max per card and a $4.95 – $5.95 purchase fee. Most people recommend only buying one at a time, because some stores have started being weird about the process and require manager approval for transactions exceeding $500. If you must, just go to another store and buy them one at a time. But don’t try to buy 10 at once, and then make a scene when they don’t allow it.

How to Liquidate VGCs

**First of all, when using the methods described below, never tell a cashier or store employee that you are using a “gift card”. They don’t understand travel hacking, and it draws suspicion, which eventually leads to trouble when a bozo manager gets involved. If asked, always say that you are using a debit card when liquidating VGCs.

There are far more ways to liquidate VGCs than there are for the Amex variety. This is because they have a pin and can be used as debit. The pin number for Vanilla Visa cards from CVS is set upon first use. The first time you use the card, you set the 4-digit pin. Super easy. Many of the other Visa gift cards have the pin preset as the last 4 digits of the card. If a pin is not present, you will need to call the issuing company and set a pin. Also easy.

I’ll list the liquidation methods in order of attractiveness.

1) Load Your Serve Account

Walmart recently announced that you can use debit cards (read VGCs) to reload your Serve account in all stores. This is excellent news. All you have to do is walk up to a cashier and say “I need to load my prepaid card.” Then hand them your Serve card and tell them how much to load.

*Update February, 2016: At the start of 2016, many people got emails from American Express saying that their Serve account could no longer be loaded (online or in stores), and suggested that the card should be liquidated and closed. This event suggests that Amex is no longer happy about using Serve for manufactured spending, and while you can still signup for Serve, I expect more accounts to be shut down in the future.

Note that Vanilla VGC sold at CVS and Walgreens no longer work at Walmart, so do not try. The VGCs bought from grocery stores will still work at Walmart to load Serve.

The Serve limits are $500 per swipe, $2,500 per day, $5,000 per calendar month. Notice how perfect this works out if you have multiple $500 prepaid cards that you can use at Walmart.

Once you transfer the money from Visa GCs to Serve, use the Serve online bill pay function to directly pay off your credit card. (See my tutorial)

2) Use Walmart Bill Pay

Walmart Money Centers actually have a process that allows you to directly pay off your credit card in store with a debit card (VGC). Tell them you want to use CheckFreePay at the register. The price is usually $0.88 or $1.88, depending on the card. This method used to be gold, but many Walmart stores have stopped supporting many payments to credit card issuers. You have to check your local store to see if this is still viable.

I often choose $1998.12 as the amount of my Walmart bill payments for several logical reasons:

  1. VGCs and many other gift cards are $500 denominations. Walmart only allows a maximum of 4 swipes per transaction (this is true for any transaction). So you can use the 4 swipes with (4) $500 VGCs for a maximum of $2,000.
  2. $2,000 minus the $1.88 charge equals a payment $1,998.12.

American Express cards cannot be paid through this method!

Just like above, Vanilla VGC from CVS or Walgreens will not work at Walmart!

Check this Flyertalk thread for more relevant data.

3) Buy Money Orders

You can easily purchase money orders at Walmart, grocery stores, or gas stations with a debit card (VGC). They usually cost between $0.50 and $1.00 per $1,000.

Make the money order out to yourself or your spouse, and deposit into your bank account(s). Be careful on the volume you are doing, and build a good relationship with your local bank, or this method might look suspicious. There are reports of banks shutting down accounts used for money orders, and there have been cases where government authorities have gotten involved and thrown around the term “money laundering.”

Just like above, Vanilla VGC from CVS or Walgreens will not work at Walmart!

Summary

To recap, here is what I do:

  1. Apply for several credit cards with big signup bonuses and get approved (Compare Cards Here)
  2. Use those cards to purchase American Express Gift Cards through an online portal (no longer working)
  3. Use my credit card to purchase Visa Gift Cards
  4. Liquidate VGC
    1. Load my Serve account(s) and use Serve to pay off the original credit card(s)
    2. Use Walmart Bill Pay to directly pay off the credit card(s)
    3. Occasionally buy money orders and deposit into my checking account(s)

I know there was a lot to chew on here, so take a minute break, then read it again. It will all start to make sense.

Travel hackers, did I miss anything?

If you enjoyed this article, join 70,000+ monthly readers

Comments

  1. By Mike

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  2. By Crystal

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  3. By Jonny Kennedy

    Reply

    • By seth

      Reply

  4. By Sunshine

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Sunshine

        Reply

  5. By Shay

    Reply

    • By Shay

      Reply

      • By Jacob

        Reply

        • By Justin

          Reply

          • By Jacob

  6. By Bobby

    Reply

  7. By Anne

    Reply

  8. By Kevin

    Reply

  9. By Helen

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  10. By Jennifer Stko

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Dg

        Reply

  11. By Mark

    Reply

  12. By Jennifer Stiko

    Reply

  13. By Paul

    Reply

  14. By Brett

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  15. By Chris

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  16. By Chris

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  17. By Charles R

    Reply

  18. By Steve

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  19. By bart

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  20. By Ryan

    Reply

    • By Chris

      Reply

  21. By Joe

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  22. By Robert

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Robert

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

          • By Robert

  23. By Jeff

    Reply

  24. By Mia

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  25. By Gene

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  26. By David

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  27. By matt

    Reply

  28. By Alex

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Alex

        Reply

  29. By Megz

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  30. By mo

    Reply

  31. By Chris

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  32. By Marsha

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  33. By CJ

    Reply

  34. By Ciara

    Reply

  35. By ed

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  36. By JB

    Reply

  37. By David

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

    • By Ron

      Reply

  38. By Aaron

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Jack

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

  39. By William

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  40. By Shawn1

    Reply

  41. By Joe

    Reply

  42. Reply

  43. By Jake

    Reply

  44. By Matt

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  45. By Michael

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  46. By Kristian

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  47. By Dee

    Reply

    • By Kenm

      Reply

  48. By phillip

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  49. By FrankinVa

    Reply

  50. By Matt

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  51. By Dan

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  52. By EE

    Reply

    • By Don

      Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  53. By Troy

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  54. By Dan

    Reply

    • By leo

      Reply

      • By Jacob

        Reply

        • By Jack

          Reply

          • By Jacob

  55. By Phil

    Reply

    • By Robbie

      Reply

  56. By Dan

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Dan

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

        • By Dan

          Reply

  57. By dan

    Reply

  58. By Rich

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Scott

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

  59. By Rob

    Reply

  60. By Mike

    Reply

    • By Nia

      Reply

      • Reply

  61. By Mr. Serve

    Reply

  62. By jediwho

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  63. By Michelle

    Reply

  64. By Eaton

    Reply

  65. By aron

    Reply

  66. By aron

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  67. By drew

    Reply

  68. By JB

    Reply

  69. By jun zhou

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  70. By Mo

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Mo

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

        • By Echick

          Reply

          • By Lee Z

  71. By sheila

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  72. By Pat

    Reply

  73. By Hilary

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

    • By Marcia

      Reply

  74. By Lou

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  75. By JUN

    Reply

  76. By Eli

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  77. By Dave

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  78. By SV

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  79. By Moshe

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  80. By PJ

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By PJ

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

          • By PJ

  81. By Ryan

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  82. By Sherrie

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  83. By Dominique

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  84. By Ryan

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  85. By Dan

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

    • By Hoang

      Reply

  86. By Josh

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  87. By Steve j

    Reply

  88. By Adam

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  89. By Lance

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  90. By Clara

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  91. By Kayla

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  92. By Aimee

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By jim

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

  93. By John

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  94. By terry

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By terry

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

          • By terry

          • By Jacob

  95. By Kenny

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  96. By Judy j

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  97. By Kent C

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By Kent C

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

          • By a!ex

          • By Jacob

  98. By Syed

    Reply

  99. By shanz

    Reply

  100. By Jesse

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  101. Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  102. Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  103. By Sam

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

  104. By Brian

    Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

    • By Jacob

      Reply

      • By James

        Reply

        • By Jacob

          Reply

          • By James

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *